A lot of people talk about getting frustrated in the early phases of learning a system (usually numbers and/or cards), specifically regarding the progress they’re making with recognition speed and fluency, and the ability to generate vividness in their images and scenes.
How long do you think you need to spend working with a single element before the association is near instantaneous and the images spring to mind in vivid detail? Do you think this would happen by spending just one minute per element? How about 5 minutes focusing on each element? 30 minutes? One hour? These seemingly small amounts of time per element can quickly stack up when you factor in every element that needs to be learned in a system.
Lets take the typical progression of a number system, starting basic with a 1-digit Person-only system (P), moving to a two element Person-Object (PO), then Person-Action-Object (PAO). I’ll calculate total time needed in order to spend X minutes with each element in the system. Then we’ll see how the time commitment ramps up for 2-digit and 3-digit systems looking at those same progressions.
| SYSTEM STRUCTURE | TOTAL ELEMENTS | 1 min PER ELEMENT | 5 mins PER ELEMENT | 10 mins PER ELEMENT | 30 mins PER ELEMENT | 1 hour PER ELEMENT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1-digit P | 10 | 10 minutes | 50 mins | 1 hour, 40 minutes | 5 hours | 10 hours |
| 1-digit PO | 20 | 20 minutes | 1 hour, 50 mins | 3 hours, 20 minutes | 10 hours | 20 hours |
| 1-digit PAO | 30 | 30 minutes | 2.5 hours | 5 hours | 15 hours | 30 hours |
| 2-digit P | 100 | 1 hour, 40 minutes | 8 hours, 20 mins | 16 hours, 40 minutes | 50 hours | 100 hours |
| 2-digit PO | 200 | 3 hours, 20 minutes | 16 hours, 50 mins | 33 hours, 20 minutes | 100 hours | 200 hours |
| 2-digit PAO | 300 | 5 hours | 25 hours | 50 hours | 150 hours | 300 hours |
| 3-digit P | 1000 | 16 hours, 40 minutes | 30 hours, 40 mins | 60 hours, 40 minutes | 500 hours | 1000 hours |
| 3-digit PO | 2000 | 33 hours, 20 minutes | 116 hours, 40 mins | 333 hours, 20 minutes | 1000 hours | 2000 hours |
| 3-digit PAO (with 2-digit A’s) | 2100 | 35 hours | 175 hours | 350 hours | 1050 hours | 2100 hours |
| 3-digit PAO (with 3-digit A’s) | 3000 | 50 hours | 250 hours | 500 hours | 1500 hours | 3000 hours |
Here’s how the numbers shake out for card systems:
| CARD SYSTEM | TOTAL ELEMENTS | 1 min PER ELEMENT | 5 mins PER ELEMENT | 10 mins PER ELEMENT | 30 mins PER ELEMENT | 1 hour PER ELEMENT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | 52 | 52 minutes | 4 hours, 20 mins | 8 hours, 40 mins | 26 hours | 52 hours |
| PO | 104 | 1 hour, 44 mins | 8 hours, 40 mins | 17 hours, 20 mins | 52 hours | 104 hours |
| PAO | 156 | 2 hours, 36 mins | 13 hours | 26 hours | 78 hours | 156 hours |
| 2-block | 1352 | 22 hours, 32 mins | 112 hours, 40 mins | 225 hours, 20 mins | 676 hours | 1352 hours |
| Full 2-card | 2704 | 45 hours, 4 mins | 225 hours, 20 mins | 450 hours, 40 mins | 1352 hours | 2704 hours |
I was thinking about this as I went through some of my stats in my Shadow System project. I’ve reviewed close to 7000 minutes in Anki, more than 115 hours, but that only translates to just about 5 minutes spent on each card pair (there are 1352 images to learn in this system). Realizing this and being realistic early on about what it was going to take helped me assess my progress and kept me from getting discouraged during the long process of building fluency with my system. (I estimate I’ve still got at least 100 hours to go until I’m comfortably fluent and can regularly hit “fast” times for a deck attempt.
Hopefully you can see the importance of being realistic with the amount of time needed to build fluency with your system. Even a relatively “simple” 2-digit PO is likely going to take 30+ hours of effort before you get to a competent level. If you dedicate an hour per day to working on it, it will take a month to get to the point where you’ve worked with each element in the system for just 10 minutes each. That is really NOT a lot of time per element. How well would you really know something if you only studied it for 10 minutes?
Keep in mind, these time estimates are just counting the time taken AFTER the system is built. A similar grid could be made for how long you need to spend thinking about what words and/or images fit each element of your system. I know that for me, it probably took an average of several minutes to come up with each element. So for my 3-digit system, you can do the math, probably another 100+ hours of work on top of what’s outlined in this grid.
This post isn’t meant to discourage folks from trying more intensive systems. It’s really meant to show the reality of what it will likely take to get to where you want to be in terms of utility with them. Realizing the effort and time needed at the outset will hopefully encourage smart learning plan creation and achievable micro-goal setting.
For those of you who are consistently top tier in competitive numbers, cards, or other events where you learned a pre-defined system, how long would you say it realistically took you to get to the speed, accuracy, and familiarity that you’re at now?