Setting realistic expectations about the time commitment needed to build familiarity and vividness with number or card systems

A lot of people talk about getting frustrated in the early phases of learning a system (usually numbers and/or cards), specifically regarding the progress they’re making with recognition speed and fluency, and the ability to generate vividness in their images and scenes.

How long do you think you need to spend working with a single element before the association is near instantaneous and the images spring to mind in vivid detail? Do you think this would happen by spending just one minute per element? How about 5 minutes focusing on each element? 30 minutes? One hour? These seemingly small amounts of time per element can quickly stack up when you factor in every element that needs to be learned in a system.

Lets take the typical progression of a number system, starting basic with a 1-digit Person-only system (P), moving to a two element Person-Object (PO), then Person-Action-Object (PAO). I’ll calculate total time needed in order to spend X minutes with each element in the system. Then we’ll see how the time commitment ramps up for 2-digit and 3-digit systems looking at those same progressions.

SYSTEM STRUCTURE TOTAL ELEMENTS 1 min PER ELEMENT 5 mins PER ELEMENT 10 mins PER ELEMENT 30 mins PER ELEMENT 1 hour PER ELEMENT
1-digit P 10 10 minutes 50 mins 1 hour, 40 minutes 5 hours 10 hours
1-digit PO 20 20 minutes 1 hour, 50 mins 3 hours, 20 minutes 10 hours 20 hours
1-digit PAO 30 30 minutes 2.5 hours 5 hours 15 hours 30 hours
2-digit P 100 1 hour, 40 minutes 8 hours, 20 mins 16 hours, 40 minutes 50 hours 100 hours
2-digit PO 200 3 hours, 20 minutes 16 hours, 50 mins 33 hours, 20 minutes 100 hours 200 hours
2-digit PAO 300 5 hours 25 hours 50 hours 150 hours 300 hours
3-digit P 1000 16 hours, 40 minutes 30 hours, 40 mins 60 hours, 40 minutes 500 hours 1000 hours
3-digit PO 2000 33 hours, 20 minutes 116 hours, 40 mins 333 hours, 20 minutes 1000 hours 2000 hours
3-digit PAO (with 2-digit A’s) 2100 35 hours 175 hours 350 hours 1050 hours 2100 hours
3-digit PAO (with 3-digit A’s) 3000 50 hours 250 hours 500 hours 1500 hours 3000 hours

Here’s how the numbers shake out for card systems:

CARD SYSTEM TOTAL ELEMENTS 1 min PER ELEMENT 5 mins PER ELEMENT 10 mins PER ELEMENT 30 mins PER ELEMENT 1 hour PER ELEMENT
P 52 52 minutes 4 hours, 20 mins 8 hours, 40 mins 26 hours 52 hours
PO 104 1 hour, 44 mins 8 hours, 40 mins 17 hours, 20 mins 52 hours 104 hours
PAO 156 2 hours, 36 mins 13 hours 26 hours 78 hours 156 hours
2-block 1352 22 hours, 32 mins 112 hours, 40 mins 225 hours, 20 mins 676 hours 1352 hours
Full 2-card 2704 45 hours, 4 mins 225 hours, 20 mins 450 hours, 40 mins 1352 hours 2704 hours

I was thinking about this as I went through some of my stats in my Shadow System project. I’ve reviewed close to 7000 minutes in Anki, more than 115 hours, but that only translates to just about 5 minutes spent on each card pair (there are 1352 images to learn in this system). Realizing this and being realistic early on about what it was going to take helped me assess my progress and kept me from getting discouraged during the long process of building fluency with my system. (I estimate I’ve still got at least 100 hours to go until I’m comfortably fluent and can regularly hit “fast” times for a deck attempt.

Hopefully you can see the importance of being realistic with the amount of time needed to build fluency with your system. Even a relatively “simple” 2-digit PO is likely going to take 30+ hours of effort before you get to a competent level. If you dedicate an hour per day to working on it, it will take a month to get to the point where you’ve worked with each element in the system for just 10 minutes each. That is really NOT a lot of time per element. How well would you really know something if you only studied it for 10 minutes?

Keep in mind, these time estimates are just counting the time taken AFTER the system is built. A similar grid could be made for how long you need to spend thinking about what words and/or images fit each element of your system. I know that for me, it probably took an average of several minutes to come up with each element. So for my 3-digit system, you can do the math, probably another 100+ hours of work on top of what’s outlined in this grid.

This post isn’t meant to discourage folks from trying more intensive systems. It’s really meant to show the reality of what it will likely take to get to where you want to be in terms of utility with them. Realizing the effort and time needed at the outset will hopefully encourage smart learning plan creation and achievable micro-goal setting.

For those of you who are consistently top tier in competitive numbers, cards, or other events where you learned a pre-defined system, how long would you say it realistically took you to get to the speed, accuracy, and familiarity that you’re at now?

18 Likes

What I also find to be frustrating is the the experience that when I stop training for a couple of days after having trained for about a week I am just as bad as was after the 2nd of training. And usually after a couple of days of training I start to doubt just about anything, like I feel that if I had just associated every 2 digit number with an image without any logic or reading numbers as letters I may have been just as fast. To elaborate on this, using logic to connect numbers to images allows you to memorise a 100 number → image list in about an hour, but this headstart doesn’t seem to pay out in the long run in a convincing way.

I was thinking a little bit more about this as I went through some of my stats in my Shadow System project. I’ve reviewed close to 7000 minutes in Anki, more than 115 hours, but that only translates to just about 5 minutes spent on each card pair (there are 1352 images to learn in this system).

I appreciate your commitment, but at the same time this raises the question for me at what amount of training does the magic of mnemonics no longer excist even if you end being extremely good at memorising that what you have trained for. I feel that the magic of any human accomplishment cannot be judged solely on the result, but that one must also look at the way that accomplishment was achieved. I think that the world strongest man competition serves as a good example of my point. When the first competition was held a buch of strong athletes of various sports such as powerlifting, weightlifting and wrestling were competing againgst one another in crazy events like lifting the back of a car or running with a refrigirator. Almost nobody trained specifically for the various events. Currently every competitor trains for all events and if you you don’t have acces to all the various implements to train with you have zero chance of winning. Even though the level is now much higher then it was originally, I feel that the sport has become boring and I feel that the magic is almost completely lost.

4 Likes

what about 3 digit OOO (triple objects) ?

I mean you don’t have to just memorize the 1000 objects, you have to be efficient in linking 3 of them nicely.

1 Like

So the time investment is all about total unique elements. If I understand correctly your OOO would contain 1000 unique elements (all objects), and you’d combine 3 elements at a time as they come up to give you a single compound image/scene that encodes 9 digits?

This would be the same number of base elements to learn as the “3-digit P” line in the grid.

1 Like

I really don’t think that demarcation line exists. I’m not sure time/effort and “magic/fascination” have to be mutually exclusive. It still feels like a cheat code for your brain at any speed. Almost more so knowing you can keep on honing it to previously unthinkable results.

A year or so ago when I first started learning about this stuff, my best time for a deck of cards was probably close to 7 or 8 minutes. It felt like magic to see the system work even at that relatively “glacial” pace. Now I’m approaching 1 minute for a deck and it still feels like magic, almost more so in fact because this pace was never something I would have thought possible for me. Even with 100+ hours of practice, it hasn’t lost that cool feeling. There’s something differently “magical” about reaching an autopilot mode and going “fast” now.

I don’t think being able to effortlessly read and comprehend books is “less magical” now than when I was in preschool learning how to sound out words phonetically. Maybe I take it for granted a bit more, but if I pause and think about what I’m doing, that “magic” is still right there.

It’s the same with music. The more you practice and the better you get the more fun you can have exploring without expending the energy of having to actively track every note and technique.

If you approach practice as a pathway to unlocking new levels of “magical experiences” using the techniques, then its not really a chore at all, its a progression and evolution of what you consider “magical.” And there’s always new goals to set and work towards.

Granted, I’m still very new to all this. I’d be interested to see if someone like @BradenExplosion or others would consider it mundane to be able to effortlessly do a deck of cards in under a minute or if after all the work it still feels cool and special and “magical” even if there isn’t much if any effort needed to hit that pace now?

4 Likes

I’ve definitely had those thoughts learning Shadow. “What if I just stuck to my 2-digit PAO? If I’d plowed 100 hours of practice into learning just 300 elements, would I be way further along than I currently am with this 2 card system and its 1300+ associations?”

I just try to look at the entire process as a learning experience first, a mental workout second, and a personal challenge with an end goal in mind third. In this way there isn’t really “wasted effort” because I’m at the very least learning about what I like and what works, I’m definitely exercising my brain, and I’m usually making progress towards that end goal.

If I was concerned about finding the “perfect” approach to maximize efficiency of time vs result in relation to the end goal, I’d be much more stressed and frustrated and second guessing my effort.

4 Likes

Here is the thing that bugs me a lot. I am very much aware of the law of diminishing returns, so the better you get the more effort is required to make a 1% improvement. So this leads to the conclusion that it is possible that after let say half a year of practice you may end up being better at another half year if you start over completely with a system that is only better/efficient by a small amount, since with the old system you would not have improved much anyway in that 2nd half year.

I am running in to the same problem with story writing. I have a short story in my head that is about a secret warehouse were someone works who stores the location of all the secret devices (like a time machine) in his memory palace because computers can be hacked and then his mind is infiltrated by a computer program that appears to him as a seductive woman pretending to be his coworker that now has accces to his thoughts by means of nanobots in his food and that program is trying to steal information from his memory palace. I end up with dealing with an endless amount of plot holes that I have to fix, so I feel like I might as well start over completely with a new and more simple story.

1 Like

I would like to chip into this line of thinking with another experience when starting my milennium PAO project.

I found that systems that reflect the way information is portrayed leads to faster image creation. so it might not always be the system, but also the information.

An example, cellphone numbers around here are generally shown and told in 2-digit pairs. Trying to create my images added the effort needed to turn 2-digit pairs in a 3-2-3 configuration. It is an extra layer of processing, and while I am not sure bout its effect on learning, it does make it feel slower.

I do think this leads to an interesting question. It is known that actively processing information (working the information, application) is more effective than passive processing (reading about it, single-step recall), so would a combined image like PAO or OOO decrease time needed to master the images because of the added active processing that comes with the forming of images?

In that train of thought it might not be too crazy to think that learning a P-system might take 10 minutes per element, while a PAO lowers it to 8 or so.

This is actually a fun bit of theory behind learning as well. The way it was always explained to me, and the way I explain it, is that there are various steps in learning.

You start by learning very fast. you master the skill, and you quickly improve. Translated to cards, you reach sub-2-minute times with some pretty smooth progression, and there is a lot of magic in both the process and the improvement. It feels like the process starts to get automatic, and the improvement happens by itself.

Then you enter a phase where you improve slower. With me that was around 1:30. I could not get faster. I might hit a 1:20 at times, but it was not consistent. The magic disappears here along with the improvement.

Next is a phase where you re-find your magic, but it is no longer found in what goes faster, but in what goes slower. you might find your hearts are always slower than other cards. So you aim your training and at the next testing moment you hit 1:20 every time. you find your hands are slipping, so you practice the finger technique needed to skip through the deck, and soon you are comfortably sitting at 1:10. Etc.

Currently I am at a comfortable 45-50 seconds. Doing digital runs with every card visible for exactly one second is generally flawless, and while it is not the same magic as when I started, finding what holds me back from reaching 40 seconds is magical in a different way.

i think this is important on another level as well. You are learning about how your mind works. I found that memory palaces sit really well with me because I have an easy time working my spatial and visual memory. Realizing that about my mind helped me understand why I can’t grasp some things: I can’t see them in the space around me. This on one side led me to try and find ways to imagine concepts spatially, which in turn helps me understand and memorized them, I found what works like you mentioned. But on the other side, it also taught me what doesn’t work, which might be just as valuable. I created techniques to find ways to make them work.

For example, I have always struggled with emotions. I understand how the mind works, I understand the neurological patterns that create emotions, but I don’t understand emotions themselves. One very simple thing that worked was to make personifications, Inside Out style. It made me able to visualize emotions, and it actually helped me understand them more.

This thought is actually describing a pattern called “analysis paralysis” :slight_smile:
Return next week for more useless facts!

Might be a bit unrelated to the discussion at hand, but this story reminds me of mental constructs called a Tulpa. It strikes a bit as a sort of reversed-tulpa, something being inserted into the mind rather than externally projected by the mind.

This is basically the analysis paralysis I mentioned in effect. Just like there is soft vs hard magic in stories (not explained and just there vs including extensive reasoning), there is also soft vs hard lore or worldbuilding. Embracing the soft side of things is an important skill in writing. You are the writer, you are god. Plotholes are explained by you saying “that is the way it is”.

After all, why should we go “moonwalking with einstein”? That makes no sense. And it shouldnt, which is why it is so great to do it.

6 Likes

I feel that just about every element in the story so far is not all that original. Like imagined persons are used in stories like “Fight Club” and “A Beautiful Mind”. And even the memory palace has now been adopted by mainstream storytellers like in the new Sherlock Holmes tv show with Cumberbatch. The seductive computer program will off course also appear in the dreams and therefore the memory palaces of the genius warehouse operator and that looks an awful lot like “Inception”.

I think however that I have 2 elements in the story that kind of make the story and are hopefully original.

So in the memory palace the genius warehouse operator who is a professional paranoid (he has to protect secrets after all) tricks the seductive program by asking her what time it is. Not seeing the trick for what it is she tells him the time in the real world. He then tries to wake up to see if the time she has given is in fact real world time. Finding this out would blow her cover. So she panics (it is a very human program by design) but the people from the office were she is created help her out by keeping him asleep by controlling his pineapple gland with the nanobots; he thinks he wakes up but he is still dreaming so she is not exposed as spyware.

In the final of the story a similar trick is deployed in that the warehouse operator has shown a vintage steampunkish watch to the spy program. She tries to give him a complement about his watch while being with him in the “real” world not knowing that that watch only excist in the memory palace. So she is exposed after all. And then the big reveal comes. The warehouse operator tells her that he is not a real person but a program just like her and that the whole “trying to steal information about the time machine” was just a test for her. She gets really mad of course, but he consoles her by telling her that she is the best program thusfar.

2 Likes

This almost exactly mirrors my experience so far. Its encouraging to hear about the process and discover the similar obstacles and approaches that you took to overcome them. I enjoy the analyzing and problem solving aspects of the self imposed goal, so it hasn’t become a chore quite yet to keep going, but I’ll definitely remember this when it inevitably gets there! Thanks for the insight!

3 Likes