How to Focus Like It’s 1990

Here’s an article about technology and focus:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/09/well/mind/concentration-focus-distraction.html

First, understand what’s distracting you.

Notifications are one major source of distraction — those pings and dings pull you out of your work and prompt you to check your texts, email or Slack. Because our brains are evolutionarily designed to pay attention to novelty, these alerts are almost impossible to ignore. And if you try to, you’ll likely find your anxiety mounting.

In one diabolical study, psychologists brought heavy and moderate smartphone users into the lab under the auspices of a different experiment. They hooked the participants up to skin conductance monitors, which measure levels of arousal, and took away their phones, telling them that they interfered with the research equipment. Then the researchers texted the participants multiple times; the phones were close enough to hear but too far away to check.

When their phones buzzed, the participants’ arousal levels spiked. “They felt like they needed to answer that text or at least see who it was from, and they couldn’t,” said Larry Rosen, a professor emeritus of psychology at California State University, Dominguez Hills and a co-author on the study. “And that gave them anxiety.”

Turning off notifications is a good way to reduce distractions — indeed, it’s a classic tip — but it won’t completely solve the problem. In her research on office workers, Dr. Mark found that external distractions accounted for only half of the interruptions in focus. The other half were prompted by an internal motivation to switch tasks. Most interesting, Dr. Mark observed that when the number of external interruptions waned, the number of self-interruptions rose.

“We get into this pattern of having short attention spans,” she said. “And if we’re not being interrupted by something external to us, then we switch gears and begin to interrupt ourselves.”

Dr. Rosen hypothesizes that these urges to self-distract are caused by stress. Research shows that heavier smartphone use is correlated with higher levels of cortisol and other markers of stress. Rising anxiety could become an internal signal to look at your texts or Twitter, even without a chime or vibration. When there are no notifications, Dr. Rosen said, people “get a strong internal sign from their anxiety system that says, ‘Oh, my gosh, I have to check in!’ And so they do.”

Reading on screen vs. paper:

Traditionally, our brains tended to read print materials more slowly, in part because we were more likely to go back and double-check what we just read. That extra time lent itself to sophisticated mental processes like critical analysis, inference, deduction and empathy.

Unfortunately, simply printing out an article or opting for a paperback book instead of your Kindle won’t guarantee that you suddenly become a more engaged reader. Our brains adapt to read in the style of the medium we use most often, and chances are you spend a lot more time reading on a screen than you do on paper. As a result, Dr. Wolf said, you likely now read in print the way you read on a screen.

“Many people have lost the ability to really immerse themselves,” she said. “We have developed a cognitive impatience about our reading.”

Related:

6 Likes

This article does a good job of summarizing the current conventional wisdom on technology and focus. I admit that I was taken in by the clickbait headline–I was a student for much of the 1990s. Unfortunately, the article doesn’t actually provide any evidence relating to focus in the 90s beyond the premise that we had less available and intrusive technology then. If anything I was a much more effective day dreamer and mind-wanderer. I didn’t have a smart phone, but that doesn’t mean that I was on-task or focused. My own mind was plenty distracting enough!

4 Likes

I didn’t bother looking up the author’s age; but let’s do some quick math here… if you’re 40 today, so born in 1983… your 90s would have been from the age of 6 to the age of 16. We should probably add another five years to it if we really wanted to talk about somebody who grew up in the 90s.

Somehow I doubt that the author is around 45, so their inside into the 90s probably comes from watching Friends, 90210, and Saved by the Bell… the problem with that kind of knowledge… intrusive technology on tv were car phones which student couldn’t effort… intrusive technology in real life was something else entirely… in 1997, the article would have read like this…

Same difference really, only that those things were even more agressive on an emotional level. Imagine above with first time mothers and researchers taking away their infants. Just far enough that they could hear them cry. The late-90s Tamagotchi would have been between that and the actual smart phone study.

Go back another 5 - 10 years and you’re talking MTV Generation. One article denotes how difficult teaching the MTV generation came to be and that during that time…

[…] today’s students have short attention spans, lower literacy rates than previous generations, and bore easily. They don’t hesitate to show their apathy and their looks, style, and age can be intimidating […]

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1300/J106v05n01_10

…and lastly, a quick look at the lyrics from a 1985 song. For those of you too young to remember, that’s about the time “personal” computers became a thing and every household started having one… btw, go back another decade and the distraction will be TVs that became abundant in every household.

[Verse 1]
Take a look at me
Wired to a machine
I never would believe it
This can’t be happening
Boxes that go beep
Little lights that leap
Tapping on a keyboard
What’s happening to me?

[Pre-Chorus]
And when the electricity
Starts to flow
The fuse that’s on my sanity
Got to blow

[Chorus]
System addict
I never can get enough
System addict
Never can give it up, oh, no

In conclusion, somehow we end up with “System Addict” by Five Star half a decade before the 90s even become a thing, but we’d like to be back in 1990 because back then technology didn’t have that much control over us.

As far as smart phones and anxiety, etc. Back in the 90s people were genuinely worried that something had happened to their loved ones when they weren’t home from work by the time they were supposed to. Back then when you got stuck in traffic for longer than an hour, you couldn’t just send a quick text or call… back then people simply assumed that you got into some sort of horrific traffic accident and stayed at that level of anxiety until you showed up at the door!

3 Likes

I plan to begin going to the library in the evenings with no access to my phone for the duration to both memorize mnemonics scripts and study chess books neither of which require any digital access.

2 Likes

I was without devices, communication, or people to talk to for six months. However, I did not increase my output. I would want to do something that wouldn’t require any mental effort rather than doing what needed to be done. I’m still trying to figure out why it didn’t work; I had the right intentions and the right environment, but…

2 Likes