Converting from Digit PAO to simple image system

I created my PAO a while ago and have practiced with it for a couple months. However I considered what scaling it up would look like. And essentially it would require another 1800 images (900 people and 900 objects) and would still only give me 8 digits per loci instead of 9 (assuming standard 3 images per loci). I decided this was way too much effort to put into the system to scale it up. (Though I do plan to turn it into a 3 digit system)

So I converted it into an impromptu major style system. I looked at my system and set each number to either the memorable object or the person previously associated with it. But now I’m am struggling to adjust to this new system and seeing the numbers as only the new things that they are and not the old PAO. For instance I might see 36 as a person I once knew instead of a computer (computer being the object I chose to go with because it was more memorable to me).

Additionally when I encode, I am incredibly unused to having to make connections between the images on the fly without PAO to guide me.

So my two questions would be: What would you advise for cementing in my mind the current images as the new images for the system. Second, what do you recommend to get my mind use to this new style of encoding that isn’t PAO.

Thanks all,
Zellion

Does this mean that you do not pre-define associations for your numbers but try to sound them out as you encounter them? (It doesn’t seem like it based on your further explanation, but your use of the word “impromptu” is throwing me off a bit…)

Remember, its not really about digits per loci or digits per scene, its about how many digits can be compressed into a single mnemonic element. It is ultimately easier to encode and recall 6 digits in two intentional elements (with a 3-digit system) than it is to encode 6 digits in three intentional elements (with a 2-digit system.) Yes, that comes with the trade off of having to learn more associations as you’ve identified. This can be too much for some, but don’t minimize the advantage a 33% greater data compression factor will give you.

Most people who “scale up” a number system don’t go for a full xxx-xxx-xxx or even a xxx-xx-xxx pao, or even a PO, they associate a SINGLE thing with each 3-digit number and organically connect them in their scenes. This can give you 6 digits with 2 elements or 9 with 3 in a scene. This is way more efficient than 6 for 3 or 8 to 4 with a 2-digit system, and “only” requires 1000 associations. If you learn a 2-digit PAO, you are already committing to 300 associations, so it really isn’t a ton more. But it will take time and patience to develop.

How long has it been since you’ve made the change? It takes time to overwrite associations. However much time you spent ingraining the old images, figure on needing to spend at least that long overwriting then with the new ones.

Over the last two years I’ve learned 3 different two-card / three-digit systems. The first had 1352 associations, the second had 2704, and the third also had 2704. Each time required replacing hundreds and hundreds of images that had been drilled to near fluency. It doesn’t happen overnight. I’m only now feeling like the previously learned associations are pretty much gone.

So be patient with yourself.

Is this difficulty due to not having an action spelled out for you?

This can feel odd at first, but I found it liberating and that it ended up giving me much more memorable scenes when I could naturally link elements with the first animation that sprang to mind when encountering them.

The more you work with your elements the more you will naturally discover what kind of linking actions naturally flow for them to use.

Can you give an example or two of what an old scene would look like and what the new scene would be for the same set of numbers?

It’s tough to do this when using the same images from prior systems. For a while you’ll probably find yourself actively thinking something like “was this the person or the object” and by pausing to consider this during memorization, it breaks your focus and flow. When your attention is taken off of the sequence of memorization and pulled to active consideration, it can be really tough to hold onto the previous information that you were trying to keep in short-term memory. I’ve found that as soon as I have to pause during an attempt and actively search my mind for the “correct” match, something in the prior scenes will get “bumped out” and it will really negatively affect the result.

So how is that avoided? Drill drill drill, exclusively with your “new” selected associations until the “alternate” image fades away. There’s really no way around it.

But the cool thing is, once you are fluent with your single association, I think its faster to encode than a PAO because you’ve eliminated a variable that you have to mentally consider during memorization. Even if you get comfortable with your PAO, there is still part of your recognition that has to parse whether a given number is supposed to be represented by a person or an action or an object. It’s like a flowchart that goes “what position is the number in (person or action or object) → if person, then this image → if action, then this image → if object, then this image.” But with a single association it just becomes “what is the number? → this is the image.” By cutting out those other decision paths, you ease the mental workload and can confidently and quickly pull the correct single associated image for each number. Then the only active work you need to do is to create the interaction and scene. The only downside to doing this with just a 2-digit system, is that repetitive imagery will become more common and that can cause potential confusion and swapping when the same image appears multiple times in an attempt. A 3-digit single association system will cut down drastically on the odds of repeats within a sequence, but again, that takes even more time and effort to build and learn.

One last note about number of loci vs. number of elements per scene that I think is worth emphasizing…

A lot of people get hung up on how many loci it takes to encode X number of digits and try all kinds of things to reduce the number of loci needed. This requires putting more elements into each scene. Some people expand the pao with other categories, like adjectives or quotes so that they can get 4x2 or even 5x2 digits per scene and use less loci. This is fine but in the end you still need to actively encode and decode the same number of total elements per attempt.

Compare that approach to simplifying your scenes and using more loci… If you only have to consider creating a scene with two intentional elements vs. three per scene, then yes you’ll need more loci. If you want to do 100 digits, you’ll need 25 loci at 4 digits per scene vs. 17 loci at 6 digits per scene, vs. 13 loci if you cram in 8 digits per scene… BUT, increasing the loci count should be fairly easy. Much easier than trying to build and recall much more complex scenes correctly, and those loci will be things that are effortless to remember. They’ll provide unique anchors for your now much shorter and simplified scenes.

I don’t know how many elements you’re trying to combine in each scene, but if you’re using 3 or more elements I’d encourage you to try simplifying it down to 2 and see how that feels. You may find that spreading your elements out across a few more loci gives you clearer and easier to build scenes than you get trying to make that extra connection between element 2 and 3 and so on within a scene. I know when I switched to only using two elements per loci, it made it SO much easier to recall my scenes. If you are confident with your memory palace sequence, the process becomes much less taxing. In my view the better option is almost always “use more loci” rather than “try to cram more stuff into fewer loci.”

Thanks for the reply!

I can see the benefit of simplifying the images per loci with fewer of them equalling the same amount of information.

I did have a thought yesterday after I made the post. Would it be better to just create a three digit system from scratch following major rules and then encode that and practice it instead of trying to overwrite the old 2 digit system. I don’t know how well it would work, but maybe my mind could see 032 as a different thing from 32?

“Better” is always a subjective term and individualized thing when it comes to memory techniques, so I can’t give you a definitive answer on whether this would be the case for you, but…

I can try to give you some objective info and tell you how it worked in my case.

Given the same level of fluency with your associations, a single association 3-digit system is objectively “better” than a single association 2-digit one. It encodes 33% more data in a single mnemonic element. It provides 10 times the variety in imagery (1000 images vs. 100.) You can use either less loci for the same number of digits, or afford less complex scenes and still get solid digit-to-scene compression.

Now the downside. Building a 3-digit system is hard. It takes a long time. If you tend to get impatient and frustrated at initial progress going slowly or you don’t want to commit to longer drilling / practice sessions, you will need to address those issues to be successful at onboarding a 3-digit system. This might be of interest:

Another thing to consider, even if you develop a 3-digit system, its highly recommended to maintain a 2-digit and a 1-digit list as well so that you can easily handle digit strings of any length that may not be divisible by 3. If you need to memorize something like “11922057276”, it would break down to 119-220-572-76, so being able to effortlessly tag a string with a single or double digit image might be necessary. So you may not really want to abandon your current 2-digit attempt however you end up proceeding.

If you base your entries on major, then yes this is an easy transition to make. 32 would be something like “MooN”, while “032” would be something like “SiMoN.” This should be a non-issue and shouldn’t really factor into the decision whether to expand the system or not.

I think with all that said, my advice to you would be to experiment with a single association 2-digit list for a bit and see if you like the feel of the freeform scene building it provides. Play around with shortening scenes and using more loci and see if it helps your recall accuracy. If you feel like you consistently make some progress with this, then keep at it for a while, when you feel like you’ve hit your limit for speed with that system or if you feel like the images are too repetetive, explore the 3-digit system. There’s also no harm in just laying out a spreadsheet with 000-999 and just kind of filling entries in here or there as you think about them, this is a good way to work with the Major System and get you even more familiar with reading numbers as sounds. This way if you ever want to really dive in, you have a little bit of head-start on building.

1 Like

Thanks for the insights!