Unorthodox Memory Principles You Stand By?

Do people have some personal principles or beliefs that they believe in strongly, even if they may strongly diverge from the common wisdom from the Art of Memory / Competitive community?

As an example I’ve heard it as common advice not to reuse memory palaces for long-term storage as it might lead to “ghost images”.
However, personally I have found this to be a benefit sometimes as it can lead to powerful and unexpected connections if the subject matters are related.

3 Likes

Forgetting is a powerful learning tool.

9 Likes

Not to use memory palaces for learning vocabulary and other non-sequential data where access speed is more important than the speed of creating the memory.

I know a few people here use or recommend memory palaces for this purpose, but to me they are the wrong data structure entirely. And people who are actually experienced in learning languages are using mnemonic techniques but specifically not memory palaces.

(To be clear: I think memory palaces are great and I use them for certain activities including stage performances.)

5 Likes

I love memorizing palaces. People tend to believe it’s tedious to memorize places, but overtime it builds up tremendously and is worth it in the long term.

3 Likes

Dovetailing with @cedar on “Forgetting” as a “tool”:

How do we use the tool?
Here’s a little on how I use it, since I totally agree with @cedar.

~brief background info., aka About Beau~

My mnemonic journey now spans a casual 15 years
—and I really decided to take it “to eleven” in December of this past year when I memorized all that Python documentation and started my current efforts to create a full-scale mnemonic database in me 'ol noggin.

When we’re talking about the power behind “Forgetting”, I suspect we’re pointing mostly at the power underlying the brain’s Reconsolidation mechanism.

Process to “use forgetting”:

  1. My initial exposure to information happens:
    • I take at least a moment to attempt to create at least a light “hook” or understanding of what I’m being exposed to.
  2. I review the initial information within the day (minutes to hours later).
  3. I review the information at least once over the next couple of days.
    • note: memory reconsolidation has NOT happened yet.
  4. I allow myself to forget the information.
    As long as I did the first 3 steps, it matters only a little how much time actually goes by.
  5. After weeks / months / years I reconsolidate.
    This is a process that strengthens connections. It cannot happen until all processes prior have happened—including forgetting.

Essentially, I find that I allow myself to really go broad (subject-wise) on what I choose to learn without worrying about reviewing subjects and information I’ve already explored…
…as long as I’ve completed steps 1-3 to get the information into what’s generally regarded as “Long Term Memory”.

This came in handy recently when…
(you know those regex commands I mentioned memorizing some months ago on my cyber syntax journal?)
…I wrote a program to parse old resumes this past week.

  • I hadn’t reviewed the regex palace in maybe a month or two, and used maybe half of what I memorized originally.
  • When I wasn’t sure how to parse certain bits of text so I looked it up to get some help, suddenly several of those unused regex pattern characters made tons of sense.

Boom. The power of reconsolidation. :exploding_head:

This sort of Ah-Ha experience happens more and more (at least it sure seems that way).
So, once I’ve done the initial few days of legwork, I’m somewhat more casual about review now. But I’m not casual about the legwork. I make sure I do steps 1-3 for anything I really want to hang onto.


Below is more on The Learning Process

very sciencey stuff blah blah :point_down:

The learning process looks something like this:

tldr version:
  1. The initial “memory trace” occurs due to novel knowledge / experiences.
  2. Your synapses consolidate the memory trace after a few minutes or hours.
  3. Your brain consolidates (called systems consolidation) into long-term memory after hours or days.
  4. Memory Reconsolidation happens after weeks / months / years.
    • In this process, your brain is actively modifying the memory to strengthen its connections.

the slightly longer vesion
Initial __'Memory Trace'__ occurs:
# AKA: a novel experience/knowledge: 
  |
[minutes / hours] go by...
  |
  \/

The __Memory Trace__ gets consolidated for the 1st time:
# called a 'synaptic consolidation'.
# happens in the first minutes/hours
  |
  |
[hours / days]  go by...
  |
  \/

the __Memory Trace__ gets consolidated a 2nd time:
# called a 'systems consolidation'.
# a 'reorganization process'
  |
  |
[weeks / months / years] go by...
  |
  \/

__Memory Reconsolidation__ occurs:
# maintains, strengthens and modifies memories already in long-term memory
# Requires 'Modification' of the memory to be considered 'reconsolidation'.

the really longwinded version
brain = YourBrain()

memory_trace = brain.acquire_novel_information(new_knowledgy_thing)
"""
The Memory Trace:
The initial state of knowledge/experience once first experienced.
I.E., it's the first thing that happens in your brain 
at the moment novel a stimulus is introduced.
"""
  |
  |
  \/
synaptic_consolidation = brain.consolidate(memory)
"""
'Synaptic Consolidation':
The "first" consolidation your brain does on that memory trace.
— It's a one-time occurrence (supposedly, but maybe not)
— Happens within minutes to hours of the initial 'memory trace'.
— A process in the hippocampal region.

More recently (2012) research suggests synaptic_consolidation is a SUB-ROUTINE of systems_consolidation (see below).
"""
  |
  |
  \/
systems_consolidation = brain.consolidate_to_neo_cortex(synaptic_consolidation)
"""
'Systems Consolidation': 
The "second" form of memory consolidation. 
—Reorganization process in which memories 
(from the hippocampal region, where memories are first encoded) 
are moved to the neo-cortex in a more permanent form of storage.
"""
  |
  |
  \/
reconsolidation = brain.reconsolidate(systems_consolidation)
"""
'Memory Reconsolidation':
The process of previously consolidated memories being recalled and actively consolidated.
— a distinct process
— it serves to maintain, strengthen and modify memories already stored in long-term memory.

! REQUIRES modification of the memory.
- It's suggested that this process is...
..."more likely to occur when new information becomes
available in the retrieval situation 
and when the reactivated representation is strong 
and controls behavior readily 
(reviewed inDudai, 2004, 2012)."

-Happens [weeks / months / years] after the initial memory trace.
"""

sources:

Tronson, N. C., & Taylor, J. R. (2007). Molecular mechanisms of memory reconsolidation. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 8(4), 262–275. doi:10.1038/nrn2090

Dudai, Y. (2004). The Neurobiology of Consolidations, Or, How Stable is the Engram? Annual Review of Psychology, 55(1), 51–86. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.55.090902.142050

Dudai, Y., Karni, A., & Born, J. (2015). The Consolidation and Transformation of Memory. Neuron, 88(1), 20–32. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.09.004

Dudai, Y. (2012). The Restless Engram: Consolidations Never End. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 35(1), 227–247. doi:10.1146/annurev-neuro-062111-150500

5 Likes

Some interesting responses here, @cedar wins the price for brevity. Somewhat intrigued by your take @Daniel_360 , as personally I would have a different perspective. But that’s exactly what I was hoping for with this thread :slight_smile:

What do you mean @masochist? I am not sure I always distinguish between “memorizing palaces” and information. But that is actually quite interesting. I’d be curious to hear you elaborate

Given my personal interests, I am definitely going to have to dive into that @beau2am
That’s superbly presented though I must say, you have a certain linguistic flair :blush:

1 Like

I am referring to purposely memorizing the layout of unfamiliar locations (typically virtual) until I am familiar with them to use them for different purposes in the future.

3 Likes

I find waltzing through an area in my mind is not always that interesting unless there’s action happening or curiosities afoot.

@masochist How do you go about reviewing palaces prior to using them as palaces?

I’ll often just pick one of the unused locations I wrote on a list and, to familiarize myself, I just go ahead and willy-nilly try to use it for memorizing information. Sometimes I just memorize random stuff (contest-style, I suppose), sometimes I just pack in things I’m already learning since I have more than enough of that anyway.

1 Like

Basically with spaced repetition. I have a written down list of loci and continuously review the loci in order until it is ingrained in my memory. I pick out very distinct points I know will stick in my mind, and if I’m having trouble remembering the loci I exaggerate it. For example when I was memorizing a beach house virtual tour, I saw a lamp on the ceiling with a weird flower design that made it look like a giant spider, so in my mind in that palace the loci is now of a stagnant spider

5 Likes

Ah, I like that. Some similarity exists between us. Occasionally I find ways to “exaggerate” or play around with an area if I find some creative association I like that’s more memorable.

On rare occasion, mundane areas are just asking to receive the 'ol “dream” remodel treatment to improve the local urban designer’s vision.
Perhaps the corner storm drain is not as interesting or noteworthy as the entrance to some new kind of hell.

I haven’t done that specific example. But I can think of a couple storm drains that might benefit from a malevolent Feng shui master’s touch.

2 Likes

I forgot one of the most interesting aspects of what I read amongst those sources I provided:

Tse et al. (2011) reported that in paired associate memory in the rat, learning of information that is postulated to be capable of being rapidly integrated into an existing knowledge schema, is associated with upregulation within minutes to hours of immediate early genes in the prelimbic region of the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC), and pharmacological interventions targeted at that area can prevent both consolidation of new learning and the recall of recently and even remotely consolidated information. This finding was taken to support a model of consolidation that posits that systems consolidation could be accomplished quickly, even within hours, provided a previously established body of related knowledge, i.e., a mental schema, is available (Tse et al., 2007);

and

In other sets of studies, the possibility was raised that the slow time course of systems consolidation is not a rigid given, but rather depends on the relevance of the new information to available knowledge (schema assimilation model) (Wang and Morris, 2010). Hence, so goes the proposal, systems consolidation could be accomplished quickly, within days or even hours, provided a previously established body of related knowledge, i.e., a mental schema, is available.

In other words, there is a strong possibility (imo it’s a reality) that “systems consolidation” can happen almost immediately (eg, same day, maybe even same hour) if an existing mental schema already exists where that knowledge can be positioned.

Isn’t that what a memory palace is?

A mental schema (ie ‘data structure’) to organize information.

This is where I think the incredible efficiency of “memorizing” syntax and reserved words and other documentation is coming into play in a neurological way. Speeding up the Systems Consolidation aspect of encoding.


Dudai, Y., Karni, A., & Born, J. (2015). The Consolidation and Transformation of Memory. Neuron, 88(1), 20–32. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2015.09.004

3 Likes

There are actually a lot of fascinating conserved mechanisms for this across studies

Here is an interesting snippet

Memory fades over time, becoming more schematic or abstract. The loss of contextual detail in memory may reflect a time-dependent change in the brain structures supporting memory. It has been well established that contextual fear memory relies on the hippocampus for expression shortly after learning, but it becomes hippocampus-independent at a later time point, a process called systems consolidation. This time-dependent process correlates with the loss of memory precision. Here, we investigated whether training intensity predicts the gradual decay of hippocampal dependency to retrieve memory, and the quality of the contextual memory representation over time. We have found that training intensity modulates the progressive decay of hippocampal dependency and memory precision. Strong training intensity accelerates systems consolidation and memory generalization in a remarkable timeframe match. The mechanisms underpinning such process are triggered by glucocorticoid and noradrenaline released during training. These results suggest that the stress levels during emotional learning act as a switch, determining the fate of memory quality. Moderate stress will create a detailed memory, whereas a highly stressful training will develop a generic gist-like memory.

Long-term memory is formed immediately without the need for protein synthesis-dependent consolidation in Drosophila | Nature Communications

System Consolidation of Spatial Memories in Mice: Effects of Enriched Environment - PMC (nih.gov)

Hippocampus | Neuroscience Journal | Wiley Online Library

2 Likes

One thing I would also point out about the neuroscientific literature on memory consolidation is that it has a heavy bias towards the experiments that are established and easy to conduct, which are often fear conditioning and induction of stress.

Furthermore, outliers are usually removed by statistical analysis tools, rather than studied.

The implication of that is that an extremely motivated human being harnessing metacognitive strategies may be able to develop seemingly “impossible” abilities from a scientific perspective.

I think there are some really fascinating opportunities at the intersection that scientists such as Boris Konrad sit at, where they both have an internal understanding of these techniques, combined with a rigorous neurobiological grounding.

1 Like

Using Rhyming Letter Getters instead of the Major System. Makes initial memorsing of numbers much easier and then progression to number strings and pairs works in the same way as other systems.

2 Likes

That if something is true, belief is unnecessary.

2 Likes

This is also a principle I’ve become interested in after someone here mentioned it.

Why Are Some Images Are More Memorable Than Others? - Neuroscience News

2 Likes

Von Restorff Effect, I believe they used to call this.

1 Like

I’m familiar with Von Restorf, but I think this extends beyond that, although they both play on the dopaminergic novelty processes in the brain.

Because coding tasks require a variety of complex skills, the brain adapts to strengthen associations between different parts of the brain. Forming these flexible intracerebral connections is a great exercise for the brain, as it strengthens its ability to learn, memorize and perform.

1 Like

Absolutely @Magno . Have you made any ventures into programs that connect memory techniques with the vast digital opportunities that computers facilitate?