The Death of PAO?

Doesn’t it depend on the event?

If I’m doing hour cards, I would use PAO-P. However, for Speed Cards, I’d go with P with the (AO) being included in the fuller and quicker image.

Here is an updated table that doesn’t include Alex’s and Lances’ new 17 and 18 second rounds for the XMT.

Rank    Competitor                  Score
1       Simon REINHARD              20.44 seconds
2       Alex MULLEN                 21.5 seconds
3       YANG Yan                    22.57 seconds
4       WANG Feng                   24.22 seconds
5       Ben PRIDMORE                24.97 seconds
6       LI Linpei                   25.04 seconds 
7       Ola Kåre RISA               25.78 seconds
8       Johannes MALLOW             26.3 seconds
9       Enkhmunkh ERDENEBATKHAAN    27.43 seconds
10      Enkhjin TUMUR               27.86 seconds

That seems like it would put Lance in the list and leave only one PAO-user in the top 10(?) I’m not sure about the systems used for all of those competitors.

1 Like

I’ve never really understood this comparison, Josh.

In a sense, does it not just highlight the flexibility of PAO? In speed cards, some people will use one image per location. However, if that image is of a person (often with an action and/or object included), I’d say they are still using the PAO system.

I think of single image systems as being in a separate category than compound images (P-A and P-A-O).

A single-image system would always use the same image for a number. There might be actions sometimes, but the actions wouldn’t represent numbers – they would only be used to enhance the images or connect them.

In a compound image system, the numbers can be encoded as more than one thing, depending on the numbers’ positions. The actions and object encode other numbers and don’t just arbitrarily enhance the mnemonic.

Example: 42 could be Arnold Schwarzenegger. He might or might not be holding weights, and no matter what he is doing or holding, the action of lifting weights or hitting something with the weights doesn’t represent data.

In my system, some numbers are represented by objects, but none are represented by actions, though some of the persons/animals/creatures and objects have associated actions that help distinguish them from similar images.

That’s how I think about it, at least. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Hi,

Do we know which system they use if they do not use PAO system ?

Best Regards
N.

2 Likes

However, if that image is of a person (often with an action and/or object included), I’d say they are still using the PAO system.

This isn’t the right way to label the methods Graham. First of all, a person doesn’t use PAO for part of the deck and then go back to using a different system based on what cards come up.

Secondly, even though they’re similar, PA and PAO are different because PAO is always 3 cards per locus and PA is always 2 cards per locus.

And I talk about another method sometimes called “PO” which I consider a totally different option than PA or PAO though I haven’t tested it. It may be the same as what some people consider to be “PA.” The difference is that one possible formulation of PA is (PA+O) and another is (P+AO). I refer to the former as PO sometimes, though I don’t know on average what most people mean when they talk about “PA.” One reason I don’t like PAO is that people and objects aren’t memorable merely for looking how they do. They are memorable because of their “essence.” So IMO if you have Tiger woods, it’s best to always have him swing his club in one way or another. That’s just my opinion on that particular matter though my more important stance is that one should ignore PA and its offshoots entirely.

I’m putting together a cradle to grave becoming a successful MA program and PA or PAO will not be a part of it. I won’t go into any other reasons here.

I’ve always had the same opinion, but, without testing it, I couldn’t really know. Right now, I am beginning to test something similar to a (P+AO), I believe, using your terminology. It’s more like Person + Power where Power is just like a “super-duper attack” video-game characters use in games such as Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat or whatever new games people are playing nowadays. And yes, they fight each other.

So, I am already experiencing exactly what you mentioned. Powers are very much the essence of the Persons, so it’s hard to untangle them. I thought it was just a beginner’s problem and all I had to do was train, train and train.

But now YOU say that. So, now I have serious doubts about using any variant of PAO.

Do you mind answering a question? I believe that in the Shadow System, you guys just throw the images in the loci, probably associating them briefly somehow. But you add more and more images until your system tell you to move on and change locus. How is this compression done? Do you keep linking these images among each other to form a “chain”, so that you know the order of them? Or do you link them somehow to the locus in a way you still keep the order?

The only advantage of PAO variants seems to be the compression of images. But (apart from the fact that you compress by using a 2-card system) if you guys can put together a few images without a PAO-like association and get the times you get, then I really don’t see the point.

What I mean is, I, as a beginner, could just try a 1-card system using the way you put cards together in a locus and change loci based on suit changes. That way, I keep the essence of my images together and still profit from some compression depending on the clumping of suits.

Has anybody tried that?

Best,
Tammish.

Sorry, but that led me to another question:

Do you mind disclosing what system you use for numbers? Since there are no suits, what kind of compression (if any) you use? Not PAO, right?

Thanks!

P.S.: I hope you are not saving all this info for the youtube videos, but I suspect you are :frowning:

@LocilnTheSky

I’d love to hear more on this. Right now I’m using person only for memorizing dates after the year 0000, and it’s working pretty well. I have O.j. Simpson and Berry Alan(Flash) for year 0621. I’m open to much better ways, but this method is so hilariously better than my Sticks/Shoe/Bun rhyming method I was relying on for school study that I really want to see examples of this.

I definitely want to learn more!

Ha. Mr. Cohen, and you can’t say, Boris Konrad uses the major system for 00-99 or 000-999 digits. I still do not understand from his book.

I haven’t read his book and am not sure exactly what number system he uses. You could ask him — his username here is Boris.

(It looks like it isn’t available in English yet, just a few other languages: German, Italian, Russian, Dutch, and Chinese.)

1 Like

Bro for dates you should convert every 3digit to image for better result or you can use shodow method.
356 -35 56
124 -12 24

It’s a pity, “How to Remember Everything,” is simply an incredible book that explains the neurophysiology of our memory with extremely clear language. No need, I have his email address. I just thought it was ugly to distract such a person for such trifles x)

1 Like

non-pao is ben system right?
Like make an image for every 2 combinations , but thats around 52*51 images.
Where do you start ?

2 Likes

Non-pao is anything that doesn’t place a PAO image in a location; so PA or OO, etc. Non-pao does not mean 3-digit instead of 2-digit system automatically.

4 Likes

Andrea Muzii is a PAO user I believe and he just came in second to Alex Mullen in the 2022 Memory League World Championship. Their matches have been back and forth whenever they’re paired up together.
Congratulations to both competitors.

6 Likes

Isn’t PAO easier when I comes to having to learn less images? 00-99! As opposed to 1,352 images in a 3-digit major system!!

4 Likes

I wouldn’t say easier… but more accessible for beginner and intermediate level… there isn’t much you can do with a one digit system other than understanding the concepts. Generally, images in locations are easier to recall if there is some sort of interaction… now, if that is a Major/Dominic/etc OO-system, PA/PO-system or PAO system doesn’t make much of a difference; however, PAO has the advantage of storing 6 instead of 4 digits.

That’s how many people end up with PAO really… just a matter of biggest bang for your buck. Starting out with a 3-dgit system is only really an option if you already know that you want to dedicate the next couple of years to making it to the top.

6 Likes

He uses PAO for cards but 3 digit for numbers. Can’t argue with Andrea’s results!

6 Likes

I guess with enough practice he can have the best of both worlds!

7 Likes